Amerika

Furthest Right

Transcendent Realism

There were only a few actual revolutions in philosophy. The first was the origin, Plato, who synthesized all previous work into a system of thought; the next arguably was Emerson, who embraced the irrationalism of the “gold and silver types” from Plato.

In his view, the question was not what we could logically deduce about life, but how to have a telos like a natural organism, that is live life for the purpose of living, which includes both Darwinian adaptation and wandering the wilds meditating on existence.

Emerson inspired Nietzsche, who realized that living-for was more important than living to avoid risk and fear. We have to have a positive forward constructive goal, like Plato’s gold and silver types, or we fall into solipsism and self-destruct.

The essence of transcendentalism emerges through this division: while most human thinking involves judging reality, the transcendentalist accepts consequentialism — that results matter more than opinions — and finds a way to discover beauty within that radical realism.

Consequently, a transcendentalist is less worried about the various sad stories out there and the pervasive misery of most of humanity than he is about the opportunities presented to us to rise above that mediocre norm.

While a hard realist, the transcendentalist recognizes the metaphysical root of all existence, running parallel to the material and physical:

[T]he Perennial Philosophy has spoken almost all the languages of Asia and Europe and has made use of the terminology and traditions of every one of the higher religions. But under all this confusion of tongues and myths, of local histories and particularist doctrines, there remains a Highest Common Factor, which is the Perennial Philosophy in what may be called its chemically pure state. This final purity can never, of course, be expressed by any verbal statement of the philosophy, however undogmatic that statement may be, however deliberately syncretistic. The very fact that it is set down at a certain time by a certain writer, using this or that language, automatically imposes a certain sociological and personal bias on the doctrines so formulated. It is only the act of contemplation when words and even personality are transcended, that the pure state of the Perennial Philosophy can actually be known. The records left by those who have known it in this way make it abundantly clear that all of them, whether Hindu, Buddhist, Hebrew, Taoist, Christian, or Mohammedan, were attempting to describe the same essentially indescribable Fact.

The original scriptures of most religions are poetical and unsystematic. Theology, which generally takes the form of a reasoned commentary on the parables and aphorisms of the scriptures, tends to make its appearance at a later stage of religious history. The Bhagavad-Gita occupies an intermediate position between scripture and theology; for it combines the poetical qualities of the first with the clear-cut methodicalness of the second. The book may be described, writes Ananda K. Coomaraswamy in his admirable Hinduism and Buddhism, “as a compendium of the whole Vedic doctrine to be found in the earlier Vedas, Brahmanas and Upanishads, and being therefore the basis of all the later developments, it can be regarded as the focus of all Indian religion” is also one of the clearest and most comprehensive summaries of the Perennial Philosophy ever to have been made. Hence its enduring value, not only for Indians, but for all mankind.

At the core of the Perennial Philosophy we find four fundamental doctrines.

  1. The phenomenal world of matter and of individualized consciousness–the world of things and animals and men and even gods–is the manifestation of a Divine Ground within which all partial realities have their being, and apart from which they would be non-existent.
  2. Human beings are capable not merely of knowing about the Divine Ground by inference; they can also realize its existence by a direct intuition, superior to discursive reasoning. This immediate knowledge unites the knower with that which is known.
  3. Man possesses a double nature, a phenomenal ego and an eternal Self, which is the inner man, the spirit, the spark of divinity within the soul. It is possible for a man, if he so desires, to identify himself with the spirit and therefore with the Divine Ground, which is of the same or like nature with the spirit.
  4. Man’s life on earth has only one end and purpose: to identify himself with his eternal Self and so to come to unitive knowledge of the Divine Ground.

In Hinduism the first of these four doctrines is stated in the most categorical terms. The Divine Ground is Brahman, whose creative, sustaining and transforming aspects are manifested the Hindu trinity. A hierarchy of manifestations connects inanimate matter with man, gods, High Gods, and the undifferentiated Godhead beyond.

We can dispense with the religion question. When abstracted enough, all the major religions agree on the fundamentals, and the rest seems to be manipulation oriented toward population control in lieu of actual culture, not religion per se.

Where does this fit with the transcendental? It is not, after all, properly metaphysical… it merely means that we view reality through a consequentialist lens and, seeing all that we find bad and good together, realize that the two bring us a world of possibilities.

Transcendentalism is a belief that pulls us forward because it is oriented toward what might become real, with some of our effort, within the framework of consistency with all that is already known to be real.

This makes it distinct from the judgment/shame/guilt/face-saving beliefs like Arabic Christianity that seek to sit in judgment on reality itself, a form of hubris disguised as humility.

In the same way, our sense of life value splits between “meaning” (symbolism, emotion) and “destiny” (purpose, role, function, duty). Those who embrace the former will forever search for definitive answers, but those seeking the latter have found them.

Destiny and purpose, as opposed to meaning and judgment, come to us from the concept of telos or having a role in the divine structure of reality:

Teleology, (from Greek telos, “end,” and logos, “reason”), explanation by reference to some purpose, end, goal, or function. Traditionally, it was also described as final causality, in contrast with explanation solely in terms of efficient causes (the origin of a change or a state of rest in something).

This fits with the transcendental but not the modern view; in the modern view, each person is self-created and needs to discover new, arbitrary things to fascinate him. In the transcendental view, each person makes choices in the context of achieving his destiny.

To the transcendental person, the search for destiny is a creative act that involves bonding with the universe through intense thinking and something a lot like meditation or prayer.

Their goal is not to fit in, in the conformist sense, but to find some niche where they can meet the universe halfway and adapt to it while exercising their own creativity and will to make make something good out of the situation.

Moderns find themselves offended by this because it is not pacifistic. Instead of saying that there is one moral right method by which we live, it suggests that we go through cycles of ignorance then analysis and introspection, eventually reaching balance.

This is similar to pink noise, or a kind of hero’s journey we undergo both in conversation and understanding our world:

Enjoyable conversations rarely follow a straight line of constant agreement, nor do they jump randomly from one unrelated remark to the next. According to a new study published in Science Advances, more rewarding chats tend to show a stronger version of a mathematical pattern known as “pink noise,” in which speakers align on a topic, drift apart to bring in fresh ideas, and reconnect. This give-and-take was linked to greater enjoyment among both strangers and friends, a deeper sense of connection among strangers, and a higher chance that speed daters agreed to a second date.

Let us review the core of the above: “speakers align on a topic, drift apart to bring in fresh ideas, and reconnect.” Like the seven stages of grief, the seven stages of ritual, or the hero’s journey, it involves a quest (topic), conflict (drift apart), negotiation, and resolution.

This is an opposite to modern linear thinking, in which there is one right method and it is applied to everything, creating peace. The conversational model rejects peace, and embraces conflict followed by mutual understanding, even if no unity of behavior was achieved.

In this way, conversation has telos: its role is to reveal where each party stands, and what their role is in the larger drama of the conflict over ideas. There is a destiny to each conversation in that it brings people into “the know,” even if on the oppositional side.

The weakness for transcendental traditionalism is individualism, or the tendency of people to draw attention to themselves above their station, focus only on what interests them to the misfortune of society, and filter out anything but what makes them feel good.

Individualism, as it turns out, has evolutionary roots in the competition between individuals, instead of a competition for achieving a goal beyond the individual:

Males produce waxy secretions from glands on their hindlimbs and deposit them on rocks and other surfaces as they move through their environment. These scent marks contain dozens of chemical compounds.

Rather than finding strong evidence that the compounds we studied help males attract females, we found that scent chemistry was more closely connected to competition among males and territorial dominance.

Achieving a goal beyond the individual requires transcendentalism, which is an appreciation for the bigger picture such that the upsetting in life and the beautiful in life are seen as necessary for one another and, more importantly, the ongoing condition of life independent from excessive entropy or inertia.

With transcendentalism, people compete with life to achieve higher versions of what already exists, trying to both fit in and raise quality levels, but without it, people compete against others, creating a false reality:

I take that term, the human beast, from my idol, Emile Zola, who published a novel entitled The Human Beast in 1888, just 29 years after Darwin’s The Origin of Species broke the stunning news that Homo sapiens — or Homo loquax, as I call him — was not created by God in his own image but was precisely that, a beast, not different in any essential way from snakes with fangs or orangutangs . . . or kangaroos. . . or the fang-proof mongoose. Darwin’s doctrine, Evolution, leapt from the pages of a scientific monograph into every level of society in Europe and America with sensational suddenness. It created a sheerly dividing line between the God-fearing bourgeoisie who were appalled, and those people of sweetness and light whose business it was to look down at the bourgeosie from a great height.

In a sane society, people compete for achievement outside of what the group does; in a dying one, people compete within the group, jockeying for position instead of trying to make an actual improvement (instead you get “progress” or symbolic self-importance).

Transcendent realism combines the hard consequentialism of adapting to life with the creativity required to see the genius of creation and to try to complement it while improving on what already is. It is the mindset of rising civilizations.

No wonder the current one refuses to understand it.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

|
Share on FacebookShare on RedditTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn