Humans fear the conflict of nature-vs-nurture because in the end, inevitably, nature must win; this deprecates the human will, wishing, pretense, and self-image. We are but slaves to the genetics with the horns.
This represents the hardest learning in human life: that we are not in control, that we did not create ourselves, and that our “choices” are usually determined by what we are, not what we in our consciousnesses think we are.
Our egos recoil at this because it means that we are part of nature, not above it; we are not gods or purely abstract thinkers, but little animals who will die without the universe noticing or anyone remembering for long. We are dust in the wind.
Even more, we no longer face a choice about the meaning of life; the meaning of life is living it, and living it includes embracing its telos or purpose, which is the perpetuation of life itself and its expansion to all areas.
We serve a role in the universe, but sadly for us, it is not as divine forces, but as basically very smart fieldmice who huddle in air conditioned homes instead of under bent branches. We are like the thrown stone posited by the philosopher Spinoza, which if asked why it was flying through the air, would respond that it intended this.
To counteract the vast feeling of emptiness that comes with these realizations, we create a human ghetto where things are more important than the vastness of the cosmos. Suddenly, social progress, socializing, money, power, and trends exist to fill the void in our souls.
As part of this human ghetto, we create the usual fiction central to social groups, namely the idea that everyone matters. An intelligent observer will note that we are shouting into the void denial of the natural condition, where no one matters, with our human judgments, opinions, and feelings to the contrary.
If you want to know why humanity is a plagued and dying species, it is that we never got over this fundamental confusion. We cannot understand how we have a role in the universe that makes us important, but that as individuals, we are dust in the wind pretending it intended that state.
Our fiction continues, following up on the assertion that all people are important with a necessary corollary. If people are important just for being people, then there cannot be a hierarchy of importance based on their ability or utility; they must be “equal.”
From this comes a stream of dependent ideas. If people are equal, the only differences in outcomes (like: wealth) come from chance, like a lottery. If all people are equal, the only reason some are poor and forgotten is that someone stole from them.
The insanity continues. We deny nature entirely; if someone has better abilities in some area than others, it is the lottery of getting the right training, having the right friends and influences, and so on. We cannot face genetics.
Humanity finds itself only a few centuries from the debate over heliocentricism versus geocentricism that got Nicolas Copernicus in hot water, and a century even from the Scopes Monkey Trial that consisted of mass rejection of the thought of Darwin/Galton about genetics and the need for upward evolution.
Everything got worse after WW2 when fear of being like Hitler forced us to abandon any eugenics programs. In the 1960s, the Left began overthrowing IQ testing itself, insisting on subjecting people to thirty years of “education” in order to prove their worth.
You can see how important it is that nature-versus-nurture be decided in favor of nurture for these people, because without that, equality dies, and with that, individualism dies, since we can no longer live for ourselves based on our own choices, but must adapt to reality its rules instead of our own arbitrary whims. It feels like dying for people to confront this because with the demise of the human ghetto of social equals, they are back to facing the cold emptiness of the universe and the reductive power of eternity.
People in the grips of this pathology are addicted to it just like others are addicted to gambling, sex, drugs, overeating, alcohol, and religion. It forms the fundamental pillar of their worldview and makes them feel important and relevant, even if the same arbitrariness that “liberates” them also means nothing that they do has significance beyond their own lifespan.
No wonder they have so many mental health problems. Nature-versus-nurture resolves only one way. In that approach, genetics is the blueprint of life, and some are genetically more gifted than others, thus need to rise in the hierarchy. That way, life itself advances, and we all benefit from being part of our role, duty, privilege, and destiny.
But to do that we must humble ourselves before nature itself, and cast aside both fake gods and fake antigods like ideology and socializing. That boots us out of the human ghetto into a world of nihilism where we are explorers seeking to discover meaning, not artists making arbitrary modern art into which we project meaning.
Nature-versus-nurture divides humanity because not all of us are advanced enough in the hierarchy of ability to think far ahead, and to see that nature is going to win because it is omniscient, omnipotent, and most of all, eternal. We have no power against that.
Thus the people who fear eternity become those oriented toward nurture, and those who can get to the stage where they skip past symbolic religions, ideology, and socializing and get to nature. With that comes some ugly realizations.
First of all, one realizes that people are not equal… nor anywhere close. The Bell Curve administrates the distribution of every ability and tendency, which means that many people are barely able to string together a conscious thought. Except for very few, less than one percent, none can understand complex economic, social, political, religious, or philosophical ideas.
Second, some people are doomed. This one hurts, but when a kid is born retarded or develops a bunch of health problems, something went wrong with genetics. Transgenders and possibly homosexuals have mutation issues too, but even more, there are lots of people who are doomed to misery by pervasive mental health problems translating into poor decision-making.
Third, we are given a role by destiny and “social mobility” can fake rising above, but only for a time. We can get more money but not change who we are, which is why most athletes and entertainers end up right back in the trailer park or ghetto tenement. Some billionaires deserve the wealth, but others are peasants pretending to be kings, and they end in appropriately sticky circumstances.
Finally, we find ourselves forced to accept cultural relativism. Our abilities and behaviors are products of our genetics, which means that others are the same, which means that we need to be near people who are genetically similar to us — of the same ethnos — in order to be minimally understand and fit in with the generally accepted standards of behavior.
The nuture people had an answer for that one, too: just throw away all accepted standards of behavior and in fact, all standards. That way everyone will feel accepted even if radically different from each other. However this results in dysfunctional third world style societies.
There will always be some who contribute things that we value as cultures, and cultures being genetic like other behaviors are dependent on groups of people like Us, and those may indeed be eternal in some corner of the universe or by some mechanism yet to be discovered, but in the end, we are merely as nature made us, and our thinking follows those lines as well.
Tags: blank slate, egalitarianism, individualism, nature-vs-nurture, scopes monkey trial